Pakistan’s Mandi System: A Structural Barrier to Agritech and Logistics

The agricultural sector in Pakistan, which contributes approximately 23% to the national GDP and employs nearly 37% of the labor force, is currently grappling with a systemic crisis rooted in its distribution network. The traditional 'mandi' system—a network of physical wholesale markets—has become a significant bottleneck, stifling the very innovation required to ensure food security and export competitiveness. At the heart of this stagnation is a complex web of intermediaries, known as 'arthis' or commission agents, who control not only the physical flow of goods but also the informal credit markets that sustain smallholder farmers. This dual role creates a cycle of dependency that prevents farmers from exploring direct-to-market digital platforms or investing in modern logistics.

From a logistics perspective, the mandi system is characterized by extreme inefficiency and a lack of transparency. Produce typically changes hands multiple times before reaching the end consumer, with each layer of intermediation adding costs while providing minimal value-added services. The physical infrastructure of these markets is often decades old, lacking essential cold chain facilities, standardized weighing systems, and moisture-controlled storage. Consequently, Pakistan suffers from post-harvest losses estimated at 30% to 40% for perishable goods like fruits and vegetables. This waste is not merely a loss of food; it represents a massive drain on the country's water, energy, and land resources, further exacerbated by a logistics network that remains largely unoptimized and manual.

“

The agricultural sector in Pakistan, which contributes approximately 23% to the national GDP and employs nearly 37% of the labor force, is currently grappling with a systemic crisis rooted in its distribution network.

The presence of the mandi system also acts as a deterrent to the burgeoning agritech sector. While startups in neighboring regions have successfully implemented 'farm-to-fork' models using data analytics and automated supply chains, Pakistani entrepreneurs face significant regulatory and cultural hurdles. The existing legal framework often mandates that certain commodities must be traded through licensed mandis, effectively outlawing direct procurement by large retailers or processors. This regulatory capture by the middleman class prevents the scaling of modern logistics solutions such as temperature-controlled trucking and automated sorting facilities, as the volume of trade remains locked within the traditional market structures.